Are you planning a romantic night out? Chatham, New Jersey, has a lot to offer. You'll find many great restaurants where you can enjoy a meal with that special someone. Here is a list of the best restaurants in Chatham, NJ. Pick one to try, and have a romantic evening with the one you love!

Northern New Jersey Real Estate Market Watch

The median sales price in Chatham increased 34% year over year. However, northern New Jersey real estate trends are always changing. Contact The Saritte Harel Team for help buying and selling homes in New Jersey.

4 Best Restaurants in Chatham, NJ, for a Romantic Dinner

1. Scalini Fedeli

63 Main St / (973) 701-9200

Is Italian food your idea of the perfect date night? Scalini Fedeli in Chatham is a fantastic choice! Since 1995, Chef Michael Cetrulo has created a warm and welcoming atmosphere surrounded by elegant decor. The menu features a mix of classic Italian dishes. You'll find the atmosphere formal in a historic building from 1740. The stunning Tuscan-style vaulted ceilings, beautifully adorned with Venetian plaster, add a touch of elegance to the space. Guests often share reviews about the attentive and friendly service, making it a go-to place for romantic nights. With its charming ambiance, Scalini Fedeli is raising the bar for fine dining in Chatham!


Our Showcased Review of "Scalini Fedeli"
"Wow! What an amazing place with a wonderfully romantic vibe! The service is exceptional, and they change the silverware with every course—how cool is that? And the food? Simply divine! The egg yolk ravioli is something you'll never forget. The salmon was delectable, cooked to perfection, and beautifully presented. It was a fantastic dining experience!" – SW, 5 Stars

2. Restaurant Serenade

6 Roosevelt Ave / (973) 701-0303

Restaurant Serenade is famous for its charming, cozy atmosphere and elegant menu. The dining experience and dishes are from the award-winning Chef James Laird. Publications like The New York Times, The Wall Street Journal, and New Jersey Monthly have featured Laird and Restaurant Serenade. Diners can expect a selection of seasonal dishes and an impressive wine list that perfectly complements the meals. Guests rave about the delicious food and friendly, attentive service. With its inviting decor, this place is perfect for couples to enjoy a lovely evening together.

3. D'oro Ristorante

219 Main Street / (973) 701-6990

With D'oro Ristorante, you have a restaurant serving a northern Italian menu on Chatham's main street. They are known for their efficient and courteous service. The food also gets great reviews, with many considering it among Chatham's best places to eat. They have a great range of pasta dishes and entrees to satisfy various tastes. The restaurant also frequently features unique specials that are worth checking out. Diners get good food, and the portions are generous without being too large. It is a great choice for a date night.

4. Gregorio's

255A Main Street / (973) 635-2777

Gregorio's Italian Mediterranean Cuisine is among the best restaurants in the area. It won a Diners' Choice award from OpenTable in 2025. Locals recommend it for the ambiance, great service, and high-quality food. This restaurant offers a nice range of appetizers, from fresh salads and Italian meatballs to crispy calamari. They have meals like shrimp scampi, meat lasagna, chicken parmesan, and rigatoni for classic Italian dishes. You can enjoy pasta dishes like mushroom ravioli, fettuccine, and shrimp linguine. They also have many entrees like pan-roasted cod, asiago-crusted chicken, shrimp risotto, and grilled salmon. After dinner, couples can check the dessert menu for treats like NY cheesecake, tiramisu, or chocolate cake.

These restaurants are selected based on Google customer ratings.

Now, enjoy your night out! Engage in deep conversations, cherish the moment, and create lasting memories together. Visit the best restaurants in Chatham, NJ, and have a wonderful time together. Along with these restaurants, you also have some great options around Morris County. Chatham is also near NYC. You could easily head there for more romantic dining destinations.

Looking for Real Estate Info for Chatham?

If you’re looking for a home in Chatham, here’s a link to a page that might interest you. It covers real estate in Chatham and some city information that may help you. Click here.

Do you need help finding a home in Chatham, New Jersey? Contact The Saritte Harel Team. We know northern New Jersey's premier communities and can help you achieve your goals. Reach out now to learn more.