Pizza isn't just food in Livingston, New Jersey—it's practically a neighborhood tradition. Livingston is home to family-run pizzerias that have been serving slices for decades. It also has newer spots, putting a modern twist on the classics. The variety is impressive, from thin-crust New York style to artisan brick oven creations. And the flavor? Even better. Let's explore the top places to get pizza in Livingston NJ.

Northern New Jersey Real Estate Market Watch

The median sale price of a home in Livingston is up 20.5% from this time last year. However, real estate trends in northern New Jersey are constantly evolving. Contact The Saritte Harel Team for expert assistance in buying and selling homes in New Jersey.

Pizza in Livingston, NJ: Check Out Some of the Top Local Pizzerias

From local favorites to top reviews and unique offerings, here's a taste of Livingston's pizza scene. These are a few standouts:

Turano's Pizza Kitchen

69 East Northfield Rd - (973) 261-8693

Turano's Pizza Kitchen offers a modern twist on a classic pizza joint, blending tradition with creativity. It is known for its artisan-style pies and unique topping combinations. The casual yet trendy setting makes it perfect for a quick lunch or a relaxed dinner. This spot earns high praise, especially for its amazing thin-crust pizza and beloved Grandma's pie. It's even known for converting dedicated New York pizza fans, serving delicious pierogis alongside its pies.

Check out this featured review of Turano's Pizza Kitchen:

"Turano's is a great choice if you're looking for a mix of classic Italian food and some options with a creative new twist. Their famous "Razor Pizza" is a must try with its super thin crust." – FG, 5 Stars

Pizzeta Italian Kitchen & Bar

62 W Mt Pleasant Ave - (973) 740-2385

Formerly known as Pizzeta Enoteca, Pizzeta Italian Kitchen & Bar provides a complete Italian dining experience. The "dressy casual" atmosphere with a bar, fireplace, and extensive wine list makes it ideal for date nights or family dinners. Aside from its thin-crust classics, Pizzeta offers gourmet creations like the Rustica and Shrimp Scampi. The wide-ranging menu includes paninis and entrees, making it a standout spot for those craving variety with a refined touch.

Livingston Pizza

73 W Mount Pleasant Ave - (973) 629-8906

A local staple, Livingston Pizza has been dishing out classic New Jersey-style pies for years. It's known for friendly service, large portions, and affordable prices. Their no-frills approach makes it a favorite for families, school nights, and anyone craving a solid, satisfying slice. A go-to for variety, the menu features everything from traditional cheese and Sicilian pies to a wide array of gourmet and white pizzas. Standouts include Baked Ziti, Livingston Supreme, Stuffed White, and Tentazione. Convenient family meal deals also make it popular for feeding a crowd.

Calabria Restaurant Bar & Pizzeria

588 S Livingston Ave - (973) 992-8496

Calabria Restaurant & Pizzeria, a true Livingston gem since 1980, has long been a local favorite for its quality and service. It offers a welcoming atmosphere with "old-fashioned hospitality," a lively bar, private rooms, and extensive options. Famous for its signature "crunchy thin" pizza, Calabria also serves a variety of gourmet pies. These include vodka sauce creations and seafood-topped specialties, perfect for larger groups and celebratory dinners.

Francos Pizza

489 S Livingston Ave - (973) 535-1998

Part of a well-known NJ pizza chain, Franco's Pizza delivers fast, reliable service and consistently great pizza. It's a go-to for dine-in and takeout, especially on busy weeknights and game days. The extensive menu features everything from classic cheese slices to baked pasta and full salads. Franco's also stands out with its creative specialty pizzas—like Drunken Grandma, Eggplant Rollatini, and Penne Alla Vodka. It also caters to dietary needs, offering gluten-free and cauliflower crust options and pizza by the slice.

Tips for Enjoying Pizza in Livingston NJ

To make the most of your pizza experience in Livingston, here are a few tips:

  • Best Times to Visit: If you prefer a quieter atmosphere, try visiting during the weekday afternoons or early evenings. Avoid weekends when places can get crowded.
  • Pairing Pizza: Many pizzerias offer excellent drink pairings, from craft beers to local wines. To complement your meal, also check out the sides, such as garlic knots or salads.
  • Catering for Large Parties: Several pizzerias offer catering options or large-party services. Be sure to inquire in advance.

Ready for a Slice of the Livingston Lifestyle?

With the rise of the Northern New Jersey real estate market, now is the time to buy or invest. If this isn't the town for you, we also sell homes all over the region. Below are just a few townships where we work for our clients.

Chatham

Westfield

Madison

Still unable to find what you'd like? Visit the Communities section for more options, or contact us for assistance. Let The Saritte Harel Team show you the best property that aligns with your vision.